Rosen Vindicated?

McClatchy's Michael Doyle consults the attorney evaluations of Supreme Court short-listers, Judges Sonia Sotomayor, Diane Wood, and Ann Williams. From his "quick read" he concludes: "Rosen may have been on to something with his piece, discomforting as it may have been . . . "

UPDATE: On the other hand, Rob Kar notes Sotomayor's evaluations are worse than they used to be, and wonders about the source of the apparent discrepancies.